Skip to main content

Eisner Novel: A Contract with God (3 Points)

 This graphic novel was a tough read for me since it brought up some pretty touchy subjects. I think that Eisner dives into some sensitive subject because it was unique from the comparably 'safe' comics that others were producing. In the first part, it deals with a man who has been told all his life that God will favor him, but God betrays his trust when he takes away the life of his adopted daughter. Initially, I thought this story might have been a criticism of God and how people use him, but it seemed to make it more about making a victim of childhood lies into a bad guy and killing him off. I felt that this story was more about the unfairness surrounding the 'truths' he was told in his childhood. He was told all of his childhood life that because he did good things and helped people, God would help him and be there for him. Yet, when he needs God, his daughter dies, and understandably, he gets upset. It is upsetting that the comic makes such a bad thing out of going through grief after being dragged through lies that adults gave him as a child for doing good things. And then killing him at the end after he decides to go back to God (albeit with some selfish intent) enforces that he is not a victim of lies that he was given as a child, but rather that he was an antagonist that somehow deserved it. 

The second story especially got to me. In the story, a man who sings in alleyways for money was 'scouted' by a woman who used to have a singing career. She gives him money to go freshen up his look, but he wastes most of the money on alcohol, and he gives a measly portion to his pregnant wife. After cheating on his wife with the singer, he goes back home to her drunk and abuses her. Having some similar experiences to this story, it was tough to read through this section. From the drunken slurring, to the wife accepting his half-hearted apology, it felt too close to home. In a way, I applaud this comic because of how well this story is told as to get such a reaction out of me. 

While especially depressing, I do think that his comics are really well-created. The characters have such specific emotions, styles, and character. The comics themselves seem like they had a lot of thought and care put into them. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

American Born Chinese (3 Points)

 I read American Born Chinese about two years ago for the Asian and Asian American Diaspora LMST Class, but I did not quite remember everything that happened, so I decided to read it again. While there are seemingly three story lines, they all merge into one at the end, which caught me off guard again the second time reading it. I definitely think this fits into the category of literary comics. Not only does it have great writing, it tells a compelling story that really makes the reader stop to think. While I cannot say that I relate to this story in the same way, I can see how this story could be relatable. I feel like this is an important novel that everyone should take a second and read. I also really enjoyed the pacing of this novel, both in the sense of the three stories coming together as one and in the panel by panel framing of the scenes. The writer understands well how to use blank panels and pages. 
Post a Comment
Read more

The Killing Joke (2 Points)

  1. What is your reaction to the text you just read? Well, there were definitely parts that I did not vibe with, but there were also parts I enjoyed. As a whole, I think it does a really good job of story-telling and creating complex characters, as well as the timing for the story was very spot on. However, I had a problem with the major 'lesson'. I'm not sure that lesson is the right choice of word, but I did not like that despite all that the Joker had done just in that night alone, Batman was still willing to help him in a peaceful manner. He traumatized two people who may not be able to walk the world in the same way that they had before this night, yet Batman wants Joker to have a better life. It almost seems like this is for a selfish reason too, since his driving force in his decision is that he could die if he does not help him. 2. What connections did you make with the story? Discuss what elements of the story with which you were able to connect? I'm not sure ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Octopus Pie Issue 1 (5 Points)

 This comic grew on me. At first, it felt very edgy for edgy's sake. Crude jokes and nasty language was used left and right, and it felt like it was just trying to appeal to a younger audience's shock factor appeal. However, as I learned more about the characters and read more of the comic, the story felt like it was evening out. The jokes felt less crude because it became more about the story rather than about trying to appeal to some certain audience from the get-go. I also was not sure how to feel about the art style at first, but that grew on me as well as I kept reading. The shaped are very simple and really reflect the characters, and the designs of the characters are simple but appealing. The diversity in cast and body types is refreshing after having spent the semester reading comics where there is not much of that. I would say the biggest off-putting this about this comic is how it feels like it does not try to take a stance. It shows the ridiculous in things like vega...
Post a Comment
Read more