Skip to main content

Eisner and Thompson: Similarities in Emotional Reaction (3 Point)

 While their art styles are very different, the way the characters move, interact, and express themselves is very similar. When it comes to comics, expressing one's self through face alone is not enough for comics with heavier topics. Less intense comics, such as some of the Sunday comics we have been reading, can get away with just using facial expressions as a way to convey a mood. I think this works because those topics do not typically necessitate a complex reaction to their environment. However, in works like Eisner's and Thompson's comics, only using faces for expressing characters could lose out on some of the nuances of the characters. 

Eisner's characters are more realistic in both their style and their expressions as compared to Thompson's, and I think this relates to the seriousness of the topics. While both of the topics presented in their comics are serious and, at times, very difficult to read, the style and characteristics of Thompson's work lends itself to being just a bit more lighthearted. We see brief periods of happiness and joy in Thompson's work, which shows in the characters as well. When a character is feeling good, they tend to become better looking in style and stand up a bit taller. When they are feeling bad, you can tell that they become more compressed. In Eisner's work, it is not as exaggerated, but a similar thing happens. The characters use very, very negative body language when upset or in a bad mood. And they become opened up (figuratively and literally).

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

American Born Chinese (3 Points)

 I read American Born Chinese about two years ago for the Asian and Asian American Diaspora LMST Class, but I did not quite remember everything that happened, so I decided to read it again. While there are seemingly three story lines, they all merge into one at the end, which caught me off guard again the second time reading it. I definitely think this fits into the category of literary comics. Not only does it have great writing, it tells a compelling story that really makes the reader stop to think. While I cannot say that I relate to this story in the same way, I can see how this story could be relatable. I feel like this is an important novel that everyone should take a second and read. I also really enjoyed the pacing of this novel, both in the sense of the three stories coming together as one and in the panel by panel framing of the scenes. The writer understands well how to use blank panels and pages. 
Post a Comment
Read more

Manga: Ghost in the Shell (5 Point)

 For this week, I read two manga: My Lesbian Experience and Ghost in the Shell. I had not seen or read anything about Ghost in the Shell, but I recognized the name and had seen the advertisements for when the live action movie came out, so I was interested in reading it. I felt that it was difficult to read at first for several reasons. The art style, at times, felt noisy to me. This, and the large amount of text on certain pages, made some of the pages a struggle to get through. Additionally, I felt that the story through me right into what was happening without explaining anything, which made it difficult to follow along with the plot. I found myself going back to reread certain part just to remind myself how the character related to the protagonist. This is both a good and bad thing to me. It makes reveals more exciting and it does not bother treating you like you are any different from the expansive world that it has created. It gives you the opportunity to learn as you read. H...
Post a Comment
Read more